换妻社区

Discussion Questions

An American Sunrise

1. The preface to An American Sunrise describes the Indian Removal Act of 1830 from the perspective of indigenous peoples who were 鈥渞ounded up with what [they] could carry,鈥� and is accompanied by a map showing one trail the Muscogee Creek Nation took to 鈥淚ndian Territory.鈥�  Were you familiar with the Indian Removal Act and the Trail of Tears before reading this collection? If so, did this account differ from or add to what you had previously heard? How so? If not, what surprised you most about this account?
   
   
2. In 鈥淓xile of Memory鈥� (p.6), the speaker is warned by 鈥渙ne who knows things鈥� not to return to her ancestral homeland, and is asked if she knows 鈥渉ow to make a peaceful road / Through human memory.鈥� Why do you think she chooses to return despite this warning? What do you think she means at the end of this poem when she says, 鈥淚 will sing [my leaving song] until the day I die鈥� (p. 19)?
   
   
3. 鈥淕rief is killing us. Anger tormenting us. Sadness eating us with disease,鈥� reads one section in 鈥淓xile of Memory鈥� (p. 10). In what ways can trauma be passed down from generation to generation?
   
   
4. 鈥淲e are in time. / There is no time, in time. / We are in a traditional Mvskoke village, far back in time,鈥� the speaker says in one section of 鈥淓xile of Memory鈥� (p. 17).  Where else in the collection does Harjo challenge assumptions about time and/or blur past, present, and future? Have you ever been in a place where you felt the blurring of past, present, and future?
   
   
5. The prose section on page 29 states that 鈥淯ntil the passage of the Indian Religious Freedom Act of 1978, it was illegal for Native citizens to practice [their] cultures. This included the making and sharing of songs and stories.鈥� What are the roles songs and stories play in a culture? Are there songs, stories, poems, prose pieces, or other practices that are important in your culture? How would the future of your culture be impacted without them?
   
   
6. In 鈥淲ashing My Mother鈥檚 Body鈥� (p. 30), the speaker imagines washing her mother鈥檚 body after her death. How does this poem relate to the larger act of historical returning that takes place in the collection? Can you think of times in your own life when you felt you needed to make peace with things 鈥渓eft undone鈥�? If so, did reading this poem make you think about those experiences in a new way?
   
   
7. Harjo brings up music and song throughout the collection, in 鈥淢vskoke Mourning Song鈥� (P. 51), 鈥淪inging Everything鈥� (p. 53), and 鈥淩abbit Invents the Saxophone鈥� (p. 75). 鈥淢ama and Papa Have the Going Home Shiprock Blues鈥� (p. 37), 鈥淔alling from the Night Sky鈥� (p. 54), and 鈥淲elcoming Song鈥� (p. 104) are labeled as songs. Were there other poems that seemed like they could be songs even if they weren鈥檛 labeled as such? If so, why? What qualities do you think music and poetry share? Are there things music can do that a poem cannot, and vice versa?  
   
   
8. Many of Harjo's poems are about the relationship between humans and nature. In 鈥淗onoring,鈥� for instance, Harjo asks the reader, 鈥淲ho sings to the plants / That are grown for our plates鈥� (p. 68)? What might Harjo be asking us to realize or remember about the natural world?
   
   
9. One way to talk about a poem is to describe its form. An American Sunrise includes poems in a range of forms, distinguished by elements such as line length (short lines, long lines, prose), line breaks (where a line starts and ends), stanza shape, capitalization, and punctuation, to name just a few. Are there places where one or more of these choices affected how you read a particular poem?
   
   
10. Throughout the collection are interview excerpts, songs, quotes, and poems from outside sources. How did their presence enhance (or detract from) your engagement with the collection? If they enhanced your engagement, which of them most resonated with you? Why?
    
    
11. In 鈥淭obacco Origin Story鈥� (p. 81), Harjo recounts a tale of how the tobacco plant came to the Muscogee Creek People. In what ways is this origin story connected to鈥攁nd disconnected from鈥攖he present day that the speaker describes? Are there particular stories that have been passed down in your own cultural heritage that you find relevant to your life today?
    
    
12.  鈥淏ecoming Seventy鈥� (p. 87) is an exploration of memories ranging from the birth of a daughter to the 鈥淪tar Wars phenomenon,鈥� presented in lines that get longer as the poem progresses. If you were to write a meditation on memory, what would it look like and what would you choose to include? What do you think the speaker means when she says that 鈥淎ll memory bends to fit" (p. 94)?
    
    
13. 鈥淏eyond鈥� (p. 95) is the only poem in the collection that is offered both in English and in translation (鈥淩en-Toh-Pvrv,鈥� p. 96). Why do you think Harjo might have wanted to offer this particular poem in both languages? How is language tied to cultural identity, and how can it be a tool for oppression or survival? What did you notice about the ways Harjo approaches both the colonial legacy of the English language and the original language of her ancestors in the collection?
    
    
14. Untitled prose passages written by Harjo appear throughout the collection, many of which involve Harjo鈥檚 grandfather from several generations back, Menahwee. What impact did reading these plainly spoken passages have for you? Did you learn anything you didn鈥檛 know from these passages? Did they build on your reading of any of the poems? Which ones and how so?
    
    
15. The book鈥檚 title poem, 鈥淎n American Sunrise,鈥� appears on page 105. What are some of the different meanings or connotations you can think of for this phrase, here and elsewhere in the book? Why do you think Harjo chose this title for her collection?
    
    
16. The last poem in the collection, 鈥淏less this Land鈥� (p. 106) harkens back to the song 鈥淭his Land is Your Land,鈥� a famous American folk song by Woody Guthrie, written after the song 鈥淕od Bless America鈥� by Kate Smith. How does this poem build on or challenge those songs? How does Harjo emphasize the history of native peoples and the land in this and other poems? Has reading An American Sunrise affected your understanding of American history?

Discussion questions from the